Both gujarat and sindh were part of bombay presidency till. What is the issue of sir creek in the rann of kutch. While the disputed area of sir creek involves only a few square miles of. Sir creek dispute latest breaking news, pictures, videos, and special reports from the economic times.
The creek, which opens up into the arabian sea, divides the gujarat state of india from the sindh province of pakistan. Sir creek dispute between india and pakistan indian. The major issue over sir creek is about understanding of the maritime boundary bw the kutch and the sindh. Sir creek is a river boundary dispute, which impacts the delineation of maritime boundaries. For an interpretative analysis, this article covers three broad aspects. The rann of kutch lies between kut gujarat on the india side and sindh on pakistan side. The actual dispute on where the boundary between india and pakistan lies on sir creek, a 96km water body that empties out into the arabian sea from the rann of.
Aug 16, 2016 sir creek is another major issue thats been waiting for a resolution for over 70 years now. I am a representative of shipowners, and also serve as a commercial arbitrator and mediator. Pakistani territory because of geomorphic changes in the sir creek river as a result of accretion. Now, however, with the chief minister of gujarat, narendra modi, demanding a freeze on the issue, the matter has become complicated. Dec 05, 2012 the creek, which opens up into the arabian sea, divides the kutch region of the indian state of gujarat with the sindh province of pakistan. The green line is the boundary as claimed by pakistan, the red line is the boundary as claimed by india. Nothing significant happened in the next few decades following the verdict, and it was only after the military clashes of 1965 between the two nations that pakistan asserted half of the rann along the 24th parallel to be a pakistani territory. Sir creek is a disputed border between pakistan and india. Sir creek listen helpinfo, originally ban ganga, is a 96 km 60 mi tidal estuary in uninhabited marshlands of indus river delta on the border of india and pakistan. Here is all you need to know about the dispute of sir creek between pakistan and india. Wca 2016 section iv security and international relations sir. Sir creek issue is defying solution because of the deep rooted syndrome of lack of trust in pakistan. India up sir creek without a paddle by sudha ramachandran bangalore among the many victims of the terrorist attacks in mumbai in november last year was a possible resolution to the indiapakistan dispute over sir creek.
Continue reading 5 write a critical note on the nature of. Sir creek issue basically water disputed between pakistan and india in rann of kutch 60 mi long. Sir creek boundary dispute blogs, comments and archive news on. Its basically a fluctuating tidal channel, not truly a flowing creek. It currently lies on the border of indias gujarat and pakistans sindh province. Pdf sir creek issue in perspective of international law.
Everything you need to know about the dispute over sir creek. Pakistan claims rights, in accordance with the bombay government resolution of 1914, to the entire waters surrounding and fed by the creek. Less focus has been given to the maritime issues between both countries, including sir creek and its. The dispute lies in the interpretation of the boundary line between kutch and sindh as depicted in a 1914 and 1925 map. Sir creek local name baan ganga is a 96 kilometres long estuary in the marshes of the rann of katch where arabian sea joins the land mass. International mechanisms through wideranging environmental treaties already exist and could ensure that the transboundary nature of ecosystems like sir creek is respected by acrimonious states through joint conservation programs. The work by the stimson centers south asia program has played a critical. India, pak talk towards resolution of sir creek issue. It is in the rann of kutch marshland east of the sir creek, which is disputed between india and pakistan. A victim of indiapakistan linkage politics find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. Gk, general studies, optional notes for upsc, ias, banking, civil services. Sir creek, disputed between india and pakistan youtube. Sir creek is named after the british representative. Sir creek dispute between india and pakistan is from decades, before independence of india.
The resolution of the sir creek dispute between india and pakistan is held up as a result of political, rather than legal reasons, an article in leading pakistani daily dawn said monday. This article examines the underpinnings of the sir creek dispute between india and pakistan to evolve a modus vivendi. Sir creek is a disputed water stream between the sindh province of pakistan and gujarat state of india in the rann of kutch. The primary focus of efforts and ideas to resolve these conflicts has been landbasedfor example, the future of kashmir, the delimitation of the line of control loc, and the siachen glacier issue. Sir creek about this sound listen helpinfo, originally ban ganga, is a 96 km long 60 mi tidal. The longstanding indiapakistan sir creek border dispute stems from the demarcation. The longstanding indiapakistan suir creek border dispute hinges in the actual demarcation from the mouth of sir creek to the top of sir creek, and from the top of sir creek eastward to a point on the line designated on the western terminus. A dispute that begs resolution sir creek issue,hindu,gs. From this point onwards, the boundary is unambigiously fixed as defined by the tribunal award of 1968. I work with maritime arbitration in both roles, and the interests of both are largely aligned. Based on maps from the early part of the century, the two governments have differing viewpoints on where the border lies.
Sir creek boundary dispute latest breaking news, pictures, videos, and special reports from the economic times. India up sir creek without a paddle pakistan defence. Sir creek resolution and neemrana dialogue society for. The sir creek is a 96 km 60 mi strip of water disputed between india and pakistan in the rann of kutch marshlands. Get ready for upsc civil services preliminary exam 2020 with insights insta 75 days revision plan. Pdf on feb 18, 2015, raghavendra mishra and others published the sir creek dispute.
Sir creek dispute free current affairs pdf download. Sir creek is a 100 km long estuary in the rann of kutch. Five south asia experts assess the importance of solving the kashmir dispute in relation to u. The indian and pakistani territorial dispute in their coastal regions covers the demarcation of approximately 100 km of the border along the sir creek.
Aug 10, 2012 sir creek local name baan ganga is a 96 kilometres long estuary in the marshes of the rann of katch where arabian sea joins the land mass. How the kashmir dispute affects security in south asia. That is why sir creek has become more contentious than ever before. Pakistan claims the whole water stream till indias land borders whereas india contends that the issue should be solved a. The creek, which opens up into the arabian sea, divides the kutch region of the indian state of gujarat with the sindh province of pakistan. Both islamabad and delhi cite the sir creek issue as an outstanding bilateral dispute that needs to be resolved.
To find answers to these questions, we need to go into little bit of history and find out exactly the reasons for fixing the boundary at sir creek in the first place. Unless the element of trust is restored through pakistani actions, attitudes and utterances, any real and meaningful progress on this, as well as other issues like siachen, looks somewhat remote. Sir creek issue pdf this article deals with the dispute over sir creek, in the. The creek opens up into the arabian sea and separates the gujarat state of india from the sindh province of pakistan.
The green line is the boundary as claimed by pakistan. From this point onwards, the boundary is unambiguously. Jul, 2009 how the kashmir dispute affects security in south asia. Kashmir dispute and the prospects of india pakistan peace process 52 ndu journal 2008, volume ii principally there existed neither constitutional nor any moral grounds for accession of the state with india in october 1947. It divides kutch region of india state gujarat, sindh region of pakistan. Other such disputes could be over a persons estate after the passing of a. Contours, implications and the way ahead raghavendra mishra s ir creek, the 17th and last drainage branch of the river indus, is a meandering.
The sir creek dispute involves a 96 km stretch of water in the rann of kutch marshlands and the last survey of the area was conducted in january 2007 with the aim to delimitate the international maritime boundary between india and pakistan. Cooperative environmental monitoring in the coastal regions. Sir creek is a 96km 60 mile estuary in the rann of ch. The sir creek dispute and the negotiation process the indiapakistan dispute over sir creek can be traced back to the preindependence period, to around 1908, when an argument ensued between the rulers of kutch and sind over a pile of firewood lying on the banks of a creek. From 1968 to 2000, negotiations over sir creek stalled until both pakistan and india signed and ratified the united nations u. Sir creek is a 96 km tidal estuary on the border of india and pakistan. It is a relatively small chapter, which traces the genesis of the dispute, negotiations held so far to resolve it and other factors that have a bearing on the dispute. The longstanding dispute hinges in the actual demarcation from the mouth of sir creek to the top of sir creek, and from the top of sir creek eastward to a point on the line designated on the western terminus. Short of conflict resolution and border dispute settlements, incremental forms of informationsharing, communication enhancement, and mutual restraint can have salutary effects and advance u. Originally named ban ganga, sir creek is named after a british representative. Everything you need to know about the dispute over sir. The goal of both is a fair, honest, fast and competitive way of resolving disputes.
This dispute impacts the demarcation of the maritime border and the. Talks between india and pakistan failed to make progress on the contentious issue of sir creek, despite the fact that the dispute over the estuary is described as one of the most. Mar 10, 2011 the sir creek is a 96 km 60 mile strip of water disputed between india and pakistan in the rann of kutch marshlands. Sir creek issue in perspective of international law. It is perhaps because the area has been the scene of fighting in the past that both sides still patrol their respective sides of the border, even if the area is not regarded by either country to be strategically significant. Resolving maritime disputes through arbitration pacific. Pakistan navys marines are deputed to monitor and defend the area.
Read more about political reasons preventing sir creek dispute resolution on business standard. From this point onwards, the boundary is unambiguously fixed as defined by the tribunal award of 1968. Political reasons preventing sir creek dispute resolution. An agreement on sir creek is yet to be concluded between india and pakistan. Pdf slides of all the environment videos, 700 slides for free video lectures and study materials on upsc ias preparation, please visit. The creek, which opens up into the arabian sea, divides the gujarat state of india. Dr rashid khan abstract the sir creek is one of the outstanding. The basic cause of the sir creek dispute lies in the interpretation of the maritime boundary line between kutch and. It is a strip of water disputed between india and pakistan in the rann of kutch marshlands. Whats the dispute between india and pakistan about sir creek. The dispute was taken up by the government of bombay gob state, which in 1914 gave its verdict, supported. Sir creek is another major issue thats been waiting for a resolution for over 70 years now. The creek opens up in the arabian sea and roughly divides the kutch region of gujarat from the sind province of pakistan.
Dec 14, 2012 many people wonder as to why such a small waterway has gained so much of importance and why no one wants to budge from their positions. The resolution to the sir creek dispute has been considered a lowhanging fruit for sometime now. Sir creek area dispute about the international border. Whats the dispute between india and pakistan about sir. A victim of indiapakistan linkage politics find, read and. Sir creek is a 96km strip of water disputed between india and pakistan in the rann of kutch marshlands. It stems from a compromise between the government of sindh in british india and the kutch darbar over. Reframing the sir creek dispute as an environmental matter may help in making questions related to demarcation less biting. The sir creek dispute, firstly dispute arises between ruler of kutch and commissioner of sindh about boundaries. The sir creek dispute and the negotiation process the indiapakistan dispute over sir creek can be traced back to the preindependence period, to around 1908, when an argument ensued between the rulers of kutch and sind over a pile of firewood lying on the banks of a creek dividing the two principalities. It has many creeks such as kajhar, padala, kori, sir etc. What is the sir creek dispute between india and pakistan. Pakistan claims the entire sir creek, with its eastern bank defined by a green line and represented on.
India and neighbourhood relations 5 write a critical note on the nature of sir creek dispute between india and pakistan, and why its still unresolved. In itself, the sir creek dispute between india and pakistan was considered the most doable. It ends with an analysis of the negotiations in the light of the framework outlined at the start of the thesis. The mouth of sir creek is a region where military sensitivities are minimal, political. Mainsgs2international relations, mainsgs1geography of india.
The sir creek dispute hinges in the actual demarcation from the mouth of sir creek to the top of sir creek, and from the top of sir creek eastward to a point on the line designated on the western terminus. The sir creek issue also has a direct bearing on the as yet undelimited maritime boundary. The indiapakistan dispute over sir creek can be traced back to the preindependence period, to around 1908, when an argument ensued between the rulers of kutch and sind over ownership of a pile of firewood lying on the banks of a creek situated between the two principalities. The creek opens up in the arabian sea and roughly divides the kutch region of gujarat from the sindh province of pakistan. However, both states now view the dispute as being moderately important because the boundary delimitation of the sir creek. Sir creek dispute pdf this article deals with the dispute over sir creek, in the. The indiapakistan dispute over sir creek can be traced back to the pre independence period, to around 1908, when an argument ensued between the rulers of. In the following article i will describe some of the issues, strengths and wea. The dispute over sir creek can be traced back to the preindependence period, to around 1908, when an argument ensued between the rulers of kutch and sind over a. The sir creek dispute concerns a 38squarekilometer estuary near the. The demarcation of the 96 km strip of water in the rann of kutch marshlands was one of the factors that contributed to the 1965 indiapakistan war. Sep 17, 2017 sir creek is a disputed water stream between the sindh province of pakistan and gujarat state of india in the rann of kutch. First, sir creek is one of the enduring disputes between.
Therefore, in the disputed region, apart from india and pakistan, there is. Pdf on jan 1, 2001, ashutosh misra and others published the sir creek boundary dispute. The basic cause of the sir creek dispute lies in the interpretation of the maritime boundary line between kutch and sindh. About sir creek sir creek is a 96 km tidal estuary on the border of india and pakistan. Mar 16, 2016 are you ready for insta 75 days revision plan upsc prelims 2020. The rann of kutch lies between gujarat on the indian side and sindh on pakistani side. Permission is granted to copy, distribute andor modify this document under the terms of the gnu free documentation license, version 1. India is bound to honour the bombay government resolution of 1914 and as such there is no dispute in sir creek but merely an issue raised by india.
1629 501 511 1111 189 884 6 107 1615 507 1606 626 824 782 52 1362 1361 801 769 634 1379 324 1390 1050 719 946 477 768 750 16 1090 202 375